Fix the errors that i send .
Cause of overrepresentation of African Americans in the American Criminal Justice System
Introduction
Class, gender, and race are the most common approachused in categorizing social groups in criminal statistics. The statistics indicate that certain groups are systematicallyoverrepresented in the criminal justice system. The social group to be focused on in the paper is African Americans. The paper will discuss issues such as policing, racial profiling, judicialbias, poverty, and unequal access to basic services. One of the main problems identified is associated with racial disparity among African Americans. A survey conducted in this field indicated that there is a high prevalence rate for inequity associated with African Americans. This is the leading cause of overrepresentation. A review of the judicial system statistics indicates that over-representation can occur due to the likeliness of being arrested or likeliness to commit a crime (Kovera, 2019).The first part of the paper will discuss institutionalized racism,which arises due to target policing, which increases the arrest rate and the media’s roles in shaping public opinion. An intersectional approach from institutional racism indicates that African Americans are mostly overrepresented in this case.Another approach to be used in the paper is creating an understanding in terms of high risk for African Americans by exploring structural factors. The structural factors to be considered in this analysis include an approach to crime and punishment, embedded ideologies, welfare status, and different levels of inequity. The last aspect is poverty, where statistics indicate that economically and socially excluded groups have a higher representation fueled by the retributivist and neoliberalism approach. Thus, the over-representation of African Americans in criminal justice can be blamed on discriminative policies and social inequality.
Overrepresentation based on over target
Targeted policing
Targeted policing can be categorized as institutionalized racism. Target policing indicates that certain groups are overrepresented because they are over-targeted rather than beinghigh offenders. Predictive policing helps policy narrow down to a particular area and concentrate resources towards restoring normalcy in the area. However, incarceration rates are not accounted for crime rates. The use of predictive policing increases the disproportionate policing leading to over-policed communities. Another important point to note is the effect of allocation of police resources and concertation on a specific area is the high rate of noticing the crime rate in the area (Brunson & Miller, 2006). Therefore, the policy will eventually find what they are looking for in the targeted area in most cases. The discrimination policy aim at African American community and ethnic neighborhood. Studies indicate that African-American adults are 5.9 times as likely to be incarcerated. Another problem is unequal reporting which widens the dichotomy between targeted areas and real crime locations.
The figure above indicates the issue of target policing.According to the figure, African Americans are the main target. This data was generated by PredPol simulation. However, the estimated drug use indicates that whites use illicit drugs more than African Americans in the area. In such cases, African Americans are more likely to get arrested. Such predictive tools are used to inform law enforcement on strategies that need to be implemented. This leads to the concept of algorithmic bias identified by Lum and Isaac. An article by Oliver also indicatesthatblacks are more likely to be stopped by police officers.Addressing this issue leads to over-representation.
Other factors leading to discriminatory policing is media and intersectionality. For example, there is a systematic portrayal of crime by the media. The culture of African Americans is used to attribute crime by media. The crime as culture tries to associate violent acts with African American culture. For instance, the blaming of guns on African American communities. The media tries to use culture as a source of explanation, which reinforces racial theory of differences(Brunson & Miller, 2006). The use of ethnic identity in the discourse of crime contributes to the depiction of African American minority people. This causes police to implement strategies that focus on the neighborhood. Lastly, on target policing is the concept of intersectionality, which is based on the increase in the number of African Americans arrested and the probability of their arrest.
Racial profiling
Racial profiling indicates that overrepresentation can occur due to higher risk factors arising from structural mechanisms.Chan (2011) indicates that the association of Black males with violence and crime has contributed to their overrepresentation in the criminal justice system. African Americans are associated with crime. This can be attributed to one sided story or racial profiling. Chan argues that there is a higher probability of an African American being stopped by police officers than a white person. Also, some people racially profile a person and classify them as offenders. In this case, police are called, and a black person can easily be arrested for questioning. A good example of racial profiling can be noted in the case of Senator Tim Scott who stated that police officers have constantly pulled him over.In his speech, he stated that the determining factor for police action is that a black person was driving a nice car. Data from stop and frisk indicated a similar approach. The data shows that only 3% of stop and frisk encounters have produced crime evidence (Chan, 2011). Most of the remaining 97% are African Americans who are frisked because of their race. Another important element to be noted in society is the proposition of African Americans and the use of force. For example, the New York examination indicated that African American makes up about 19% of the Minneapolis population. However, they are victims in the use of force incidents (58%). Another study indicated that blacks are more likely to be searched after being stopped. The frequency of being stopped reduces at night whenpolice are unable to identify the race. The paper indicates that white people are more likely to be found with illicit drugs.Lastly, African Americans are 2.5 times more likely to be killed by police officers. These factors provide an overview of racial profiling, which led to the arrest of more African Americans,causing them to be overrepresented. The case of the senator and other high profile African Americans indicates social experience.
Judicial biases
African Americans are mostly represented by public attorneys once arrested. The cause of this bias is based on policies that disadvantage the poor people. The issue can be noted in Louisiana, where they have sued the state for crushing caseloads and inadequate funding of indigent defenseprograms. Another bias is on advice provided by attorney. Porter (2013) argues that young African American suspects are lured into accepting charges for crimes they did not commit by public attorneys to terminate cases (Porter, 2013). Latinos and African Americans make 29% of the American population. However, a review of the USA prison system indicates that the two groups make 57% of the USA prison population. The rate can be noted in terms of drug office where about 277000 are imprisoned for the offense with 56% being Latinos or African Americans.Factors leading to this outcome include biased use of discretion,policies that disadvantage African Americans, and policies that disadvantage the poor. Another factor leading to the over-representation of African Americans, especially black men, is collateral consequences associated with criminal records. There are several challenges that people face while re-entering society even after completing their term of incarceration. Dumont et al. (2013) blame the habitual offender law for the high number of African American males in prison (Dumont et al., 2013). African Americans are the most impacted and hence require legal assistance or representation to ensure they can successfullysecure a job.
Poverty
Examination of the criminal data statistics indicates the aspect of social-economic factors. Analysis indicates that socio-economically deprived groups such as African American community are more likely victims and perpetrators of crime.One of the main determinants of over-incarceration is inequity.Over-incarceration in this case include joblessness, living condition, peer influence, drug use, and school failure(Committee, 2014). According to the Committee on Causes and Consequences of High Rates of Incarceration (2014), most African Americans live in poor neighborhoods prone to crime. This factor increases their chance of being arrested. These factors include; most African Americans cannot pay bails, alcohol and drugs abuse among African Americans, engagement in drug trafficking among African Americans, and Increased chances of joining criminal gangs to escape poverty.
Most African American communities are concentrated in areas with low access to public services. Therefore, economic inequity leads to higher risks. In most cases, crime can arise in this area as an expression of structural disadvantage or conflict.Lack of social mobility such as opportunities and the reproduction of the inequalities in cultural, social, and economic factors leads to overrepresentation of African Americans.Overrepresentation is essential in mitigating the risk and ensuring social justice.
Unequal access to basic services
Welfare differences lead to different levels of inequity in access to basic services. According to Tannis (2017), the low level of education among African Americans compared to whites increases their chances of being arrested and incarcerated. The inequity level can be noted due to low job protection and highly individualistic liberal welfare. Therefore, there are low mechanisms implemented to prevent crime compared to a Scandinavian social democratic welfare state.High rate of unemployment among African Americans compared to whites. Inequity and incarceration are addressed by limiting risk factors in the community, especially for the minority. This can also be supported by ideologies and the approach to crime in the country. Overrepresentation and natural incarceration of African Americans arise when a crime is punishable for the simple fact it’s a crime.
Conclusion
African Americans are over-represented due to policing, racial profiling, judicial bias, poverty, and unequal access to basic services. The paper classifies them as into two categories; institutionalized racism and structural factors. The paper indicates how these factors can lead to more arrests or accusations of people based on their culture, increasingrepresentation. Discriminative policies and social inequality can be blamed for the overrepresentation of African Americans in the criminal justice system. Some of the factors contributing to the increased incarceration rate among African Americans include policing, racial profiling, judicial biases, poverty, and lack of access to essential services.
Questions
• Provide one example of a place where you have used rhetorical appeals or source material to support your argument. How does this enhance your essay?
The rhetoric appeal has been used in the conclusion and provision of credible sources to support the argument. The solution provided in conclusion contains a logical approach that can be used to mitigate the problem. On the other hand, differentsurveys and credible sources have been used.
• Touchstone 4 is a revision of this draft. What kind of feedback would be helpful for you as you revise? Are there parts of your draft that you’re uncertain of?
One of the key areas that helped was the introduction and the thesis statement. The audience should be able to get an overview of the topic and the arguments. Another aspect is the use of resources to support arguments in the paper.
1. Touchstone 3.2 Rubric and Feedback
|
Rubric Category
|
Feedback
|
Score (acceptable, needs improvement etc.)
|
Argument Development and Support
|
The argument is not fully developed; while it is supported by some relevant details, including rhetorical appeals and source material, some aspects of the argument are neglected.
|
28/40
Acceptable
|
Research
|
Does not cite sources, or citation is consistently inappropriate; does not reference sources and/or sources are not credible or appropriate.
|
8/30
Non performance
|
Organization
|
Includes all of the required components of an argumentative research paper, including an introduction with background information, an argumentative thesis, an adequate number of body paragraphs with topic sentences, a body paragraph addressing counterargument(s), and a conclusion with a concluding statement.
|
10/15 proficient
|
Style
|
Demonstrates generally effective style choices, but may include occasional redundancies, imprecise language, poor word choice, and/or repetitive sentence structures.
|
3 /5 proficient
|
Conventions
|
There are consistent significant errors in grammar, punctuation, spelling, capitalization, formatting, and usage.
|
0/5
Non performance
|
Reflection
|
Fine reflections
|
4/5
proficient
|
Overall Score and Feedback:53/100
I have inserted comment in the text for things to think about. The paper did have many strong points, but missing evidence to back up your points. Review and make sure you cover all areas that need to be cited
There are places in which you do not cite evidence to back up your well-made points, and in many places there needs to be much better proofing of the document. I hope my comments are helpful for your final paper.
|